Daphna, Not Daphne

Hot! In Urban

by Laura Hartley

Uploaded 27 Jun 2008 — 33 favorites

© Laura Hartley

We went back to New Orleans three weeks ago. We both have family roots there, and Jake played rugby for Tulane. We viewed the devastation. We both already know, though, that the years of poverty and generations "on the dole" there had set in place a sort of desperate disaster there for many, many years before the storm that flooded the city did. Many people there believe the storm was the best thing that could've happened, in retrospect, to give the city back some pride and to get some new buildings and houses built...and so, they wait.

Jake, feeling melancholy and wanting a remembrance of the things of New Orleans that were familiar, took me back round Marengo Street, near where he'd lived in college. In fact, we found the old house. But it was a shell of its former rugby hooligan days, where crazy parties and proud, young, drunk ruggers stood their ground.

It was empty and near ruin; water damage all over, roof missing. A neighbor of questionable authority told us, "That's Daphna's house now. She don't like guests."

Intrigued, we entered. Straight away we saw her in the parlor, half mad, half beautiful, mumbling and possibly not yet aware we stood, watching, transfixed.

I called to her, "Daphne?" "No," she replied, "Daphna, not Daphne," a phrase she would utter somewhat incoherently for many moments throughout our stay. "Daphna."

Jake said, "Do you live here now? What happened to Mr. Billeaudeaux?" She said, "He gone. I am waitin for Ben. Waitin for Ben."

Ben soon arrived, delivering a meal. But that was not his name. He said he was Henry. He did not wish to be photographed. He told us Daphna is lost, mentally and physically, and that her son Ben died in the storm, or in a war, or who knows, he said. So she waits. He said, she waits at the window, afraid. He said she is schizophrenic, but has no insurance and had to be released from State Hospital for room for those more badly in need after the storm. And he left, other meals to deliver to other shut-ins and crazees. Hey, his words, not mine.

I had but one roll of damaged 120 Tri-X film left for the Hasselblad, as I had accidentally dropped it in murky, oily water in Harahan, the other side of the river.

Thinking, what would Paul Lavalle do (a JPGer who uses old and damaged film beautifully), I went for it. The film was moist, and splattery in spots, but I did get these two or three good images. Some of the film’s emulsion was gone in spots, and the silver seemed to gather in the developer in processing. But hey, not bad for a day’s work.

Here is Daphna, not Daphne, huddled, rocking, waiting for Ben, her few and scant small possessions, sitting beside her on her mattress.

In life, we do animal rescue. But as never before in these broken moments, I wished I had had the way and means to do people rescue. For in this troubled person, I know there lies a heart that beats as mine does; a soul that longs, as mine does, to be free.

In the story Daphna, Not Daphne.

15 responses

  • Catherine Kurvink

    Catherine Kurvink gave props (27 Jun 2008):

    A profoundly sad photo, Laura. But stunningly evocative. Thank you for sharing. xoxo

  • Laura Hartley

    Laura Hartley gave props (27 Jun 2008):

    Your welcome Cat - we love you!

  • Penny Nannini

    Penny Nannini   gave props (27 Jun 2008):

    I'm at a loss for words...such sad beauty

  • Paul Lavallee

    Paul Lavallee   gave props (27 Jun 2008):

    woah! its a prividge to me mentioned below such a beautiful and powerful photo, thank you so much!

  • Laura Hartley

    Laura Hartley gave props (27 Jun 2008):

    The honor is MINE, Paul; you are a supreme inspiration!

  • Chris Whitney

    Chris Whitney said (27 Jun 2008):

    Laura-this is a very powerful story on many levels. The human catastrophe seems to linger so much longer than the physical damage to the city.

  • Frederic Frognier

    Frederic Frognier gave props (27 Jun 2008):

    This is amazing

  • Laura Hartley

    Laura Hartley gave props (27 Jun 2008):

    Amen, Peggy, Chris, ALL...there, but for the Grace of God, go I....

  • Anne Mcginn

    Anne Mcginn gave props (28 Jun 2008):

    laura, this breaks my heart

  • peggy gardner

    peggy gardner gave props (29 Jun 2008):

    I don't know what happened to my comment, but this is beautiful.

  • Laura Hartley

    Laura Hartley gave props (29 Jun 2008):

    It ripped our hearts out to leave her here, knowng how mentall ill she is, but we did take comfort knowing she lieky is so demented at this point, she actually does NOT kow how far gone she is. Mental illness is a hideous destroyer of lives - worse than hurricanes for the numbers affected - and yes, I speak from experience! THANK YOU, all, I am humbled.

  • Laura Hartley

    Laura Hartley said (29 Jun 2008):

    It ripped our hearts out to leave her here, knowng how mentally ill she is, but we did take comfort knowing she likely is so demented at this point, she actually does NOT know how far gone she is. Mental illness is a hideous destroyer of lives - worse than hurricanes for the numbers affected - and yes, I speak from experience! THANK YOU, all, I am humbled.

  • Ashley Parsons

    Ashley Parsons gave props (29 Jun 2008):

    your photos are wonderful, and i love all the explanation to them too. really great!

  • Lisa Slifko

    Lisa Slifko gave props (1 Jul 2008):

    Awesome Laura!! I love it

  • Laurie Search

    Laurie Search gave props (8 Jul 2008):

    Wow, what a story.

To add your comment, Log in or sign up!